New York City is famous for its amazing pizza. You can find all kinds of pizza here, from traditional New York-style slices to fancy Neapolitan ones. In this guide, we’ll talk about the best spots to get pizza in NYC. We’ll tell you everything you need to know to enjoy a tasty pie.
At L’Industrie Pizzeria, they get creative with their pizza toppings. If you want a taste of Italy, Zero Otto Nove is the place to go. And if you’re looking for a classic New York slice, Bellucci Pizza has you covered. These places are like landmarks for pizza lovers in the city. They serve some of the best pizza you can find anywhere.
We got recommendations for these places from experts who know their pizza stuff. People like Adam Kuban, who writes about pizza, Will Guidara, who owns restaurants, and Joshua David Stein, a food writer. So, whether you’ve lived in New York all your life or you’re just visiting and want to try some famous pizza, get ready to find the best slices in NYC.
Best Pizza Spots in NYC
1. L’Industrie Pizzeria
L’Industrie Pizzeria, located at 254 S 2nd St, is a popular spot in Williamsburg. People love it because they serve really tasty pizza. The place is famous for making both traditional and unique pizzas. One thing that sets them apart is how they make their pizza crusts. They use natural fermentation and special techniques to make the crusts very thin.
One pizza you should definitely try is their burrata slice. It’s a special slice that has a delicious mix of creamy burrata cheese and tangy tomato sauce. You can enjoy this slice either at the bar or outside on their big patio.
L’Industrie Pizzeria is always busy because their pizzas are so good. If you’re in the mood for some great pizza, this is one of the best spots in NYC.
2. Zero Otto Nove
Zero Otto Nove is a restaurant found at 2357 Arthur Ave. It’s known for its delicious Neapolitan-style pizza cooked in a wood-fired oven and pasta made right in the restaurant by Chef Roberto Paciullo. The menu has lots of choices, like the classic Margherita pizza or special ones like “La Riccardo,” which has butternut squash puree, smoked mozzarella, spicy pancetta, and basil.
They also serve different pasta dishes, like pasta al forno, which is like a pasta casserole, and veal scaloppini served with grilled zucchini ribbons and fontina cheese. It’s a great place to enjoy traditional Italian food made with care and skill!
3. Pizza at Prince Street
At Prince Street Pizza, they make really yummy pizza using recipes passed down through generations in their Sicilian family. These recipes have been around for a long time, so you can trust they’re tasty. Their pizzas are not round like usual; instead, they’re square-shaped and have names inspired by streets in their neighborhood.
They prepare the dough by hand, giving it a crispy outer layer and a soft inside. Besides, they create their own sauces and use unique toppings. They believe that if you can add something to pasta, it can go on pizza too! Some of their special pizzas include the Green Machine pesto pizza, Vodka Fra Diavolo, and Broadway Breadcrumb pizza topped with seasoned breadcrumbs. You can visit them at 27 Prince St.
Also Read: 21 Best Pizza Spots in the Twin Cities | Minnesota Guide
4. Mama’s TOO!
If you’re looking for delicious pizza in New York, check out Mama’s TOO! It’s located at 2750 Broadway. People love Mama’s TOO! because they make amazing pizza. One of their most popular pizzas is the Hot Soppressata with honey. Customers say it’s really tasty. The pizza has a crispy texture, almost like caramelized crunchiness.
And it’s full of flavor! When you go to Mama’s TOO!, you’re sure to have a great time eating their perfect slices of pizza as it is considered one f the best spots in NYC.
5. Pizza at Bellucci’s
Bellucci Pizza is a place on 2904 30th Avenue where you can get some really tasty pizza. It’s not just any pizza; it’s a special kind that mixes New York style with a bit of New York and Neapolitan styles. This makes it unique and loved by many.
The person behind these amazing pizzas is Andrew Bellucci. He’s the expert pizza maker who knows how to make pizzas that people can’t get enough of. It’s a family-owned restaurant, which means it’s run by a family who really cares about the food they serve.
What makes Bellucci Pizza stand out is the way they make their pizzas. They use really fresh and good-quality ingredients. They pay extra attention to the crust, making sure it’s just perfect. When you take a bite, you’ll notice the crust is thin and crispy, and the flavors burst in your mouth. It’s a pizza experience like no other.
So, if you’re craving some amazing pizza, head over to Bellucci Pizza. You won’t be disappointed as it is one of the best pizza spots in NYC.
6. Thin-Crust Pizza at Rubirosa
Rubirosa Pizza is a popular spot in the NoLita area. They’re known for their thin-crust pizzas that have been made using a traditional New York family recipe for over 60 years. Choosing what kind of pizza to get can be tough because they have so many tasty options. But don’t worry, Rubirosa has a solution: their special ‘Tie-Dye’ pizza.
This unique pizza combines classic tomato sauce, vodka sauce, and pesto, giving you the best of all worlds in one slice! You can find Rubirosa Pizza at 235 Mulberry St.
7. Louie’s
Louie’s Pizzeria sits snugly on 8134 Baxter Ave #1, offering a taste of old-school pizza in Queens. They’re famous for their “grandma” slice or pie, which many folks love. But it’s not just pizza they serve; you can also grab a delicious ribeye steak, a hit with those who aren’t in the mood for pizza.
Even though the neighborhood is known for its Thai food, Louie’s stands out. Why? Well, they make their pizza in squares, which is a bit different from the usual round ones. Locals and visitors both enjoy this unique style of pizza, making Louie’s a special spot in Queens.
8. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
Located at 114 10th Ave, Artichoke Basille’s Pizza is a popular spot known for its huge pizza slices. One of their most loved pizzas is the artichoke pizza. People can’t get enough of it! Imagine a pizza with a creamy, filling taste that feels like a treat. It’s so big you might want to share it with friends.
If you’re not close by, don’t worry! You can order online or have it shipped anywhere in the country. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza wants everyone to enjoy their tasty pizzas, no matter where they are. So, if you’re a pizza lover, this place is definitely worth checking out!
Also Read: 21 Best Places to Eat in Anaheim in 2024 | Anaheim Neighborhood Guide
9. Lombardi’s Pizza: A Historic Gem in Little Italy
Lombardi’s Pizza, founded way back in 1905, holds the title of “America’s First Pizzeria,” making it a famous spot in Little Italy. They cook their pizzas in a special oven fueled by coal, giving them a unique smoky flavor. Each pizza is topped with simple ingredients: a basic tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese made from whole milk, and fragrant basil leaves.
Alongside classic options, Lombardi’s offers some special pies you won’t find anywhere else. One example is the Breaded Eggplant and Ricotta pie, which features a crispy breaded eggplant and creamy ricotta cheese on a red sauce base. Another popular choice is the Clam Pie, loaded with almost three dozen fresh clams, romano cheese, parsley, and a hint of lemon. You can find Lombardi’s at 32 Spring St., where it continues to attract pizza lovers from all over.
10. Detroit-Style Pizza at Emily in NYC
When you think of New York City, you might imagine its famous thin-crust pizza. But did you know there’s a place called Emily that makes a different kind of pizza? Emily is a restaurant in the West Village that makes what’s called Detroit-style pizza. Instead of being flat and crispy, this pizza is thick and fluffy, with a crust that’s crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside.
Emily’s pizzas are baked in a special oven that uses wood for heat. They put all sorts of tasty toppings on their pizzas, like pickled vegetables, spicy chili, sweet caramelized onions, creamy gouda cheese, flavorful mushroom cream with truffle oil, crunchy pickles, nutty pistachios, and zesty Szechuan oil.
You won’t find these kinds of toppings at your usual pizza place in NYC! If you want to try Emily’s pizza, you can find them at 35 Downing St. in the city. So, if you’re craving something different from the typical New York slice, give Emily a try for a unique and delicious pizza experience!
11. L&B Spumoni Gardens
Located at 2725 86th St, L&B Spumoni Gardens is a classic Italian restaurant famous for its tasty Sicilian pizzas and delightful ice cream. Since 1939, this eatery has been delighting customers with its special recipes. The pizza here is like no other – it’s soft, with a delicious tomato sauce and lots of gooey mozzarella cheese. It’s the perfect comfort food that everyone loves.
In the summer, you can enjoy your meal outside, soaking up the sun and enjoying the fresh air. But don’t worry if it’s cold outside because they’ve recently spruced up their indoor dining area, making it cozy and warm for you to enjoy your food even when it’s chilly.
L&B Spumoni Gardens is not just any pizza place; it’s a place where you can experience authentic Italian flavors in every bite and one of the best pizza spots in NYC. Whether you’re craving a cheesy slice of pizza or a sweet treat like their famous spumoni ice cream, this is the place to be. So, next time you’re in the neighborhood, be sure to stop by and treat yourself to some delicious food that’ll warm your heart.
12. Fini Pizza
Fini Pizza is a cozy pizza joint situated in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. People love it for its tasty New York style pizzas. Sean Feeney owns the place. They’re all about making traditional pizzas with their own twist. One pizza that everyone loves is the tomato pie.
The atmosphere at Fini Pizza is friendly and uncomplicated. It’s the kind of place where you feel comfortable as soon as you walk in. If you’re looking for a genuine taste of New York pizza, Fini Pizza is the spot to check out.